We apply field-cycling (FC) 31P nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) to access the reorientational susceptibility of two glass formers, m-tricresyl phosphate (m-TCP) and tri-butyl phosphate (TBP). Although FC 31P studies are still instrumentally demanding, together with FC 1H data, they provide site-resolved information. A crossover from dipolar relaxation at low frequencies to relaxation determined by chemical shift anisotropy at high frequencies and probed by conventional NMR is identified. A comparison is made between dielectric (DS) and depolarized light scattering (DLS) relaxation spectra demonstrating similar behavior close to Tg, including an excess wing contribution for m-TCP. The time constants of 31P NMR and DLS, probing the molecular core, agree. The 1H data monitoring the dynamics of the phenyl groups yield slightly shorter correlation times. At high temperatures, the DS relaxation spectra show a bimodal character: a fast component in agreement with 1H data, and a slow component much slower than 31P NMR and DLS suggest. We discuss the possible origins of the slow component. All time constants tend to merge toward Tg. Hence, we propose that site-specific dynamics disappear and a common α-relaxation establishes near Tg. In addition, we compare the diffusion coefficient D(T) determined by FC and static field gradient 1H NMR. Concerning TBP, we present FC 31P data of both α- and β-processes. Regarding the latter, we compare the DS and NMR susceptibility on absolute scale, yielding a significantly stronger β-relaxation in the 31P NMR spectra.