The preload concept proposes that an optimal torque exists to which implant prosthetic retaining screws should be tightened. According to this theory, the preload prevents separation of implant components, thus protecting the screw from fracture. Recent research suggests that most implant-retained prostheses in function today were placed using improper preloads. The purpose of this investigation was to determine whether or not improper preloading of prosthetic implant-retaining screws would adversely affect their ultimate tensile strength. Fifteen Nobelpharma-slotted gold screws from one lot were tightened to 6, 10, and 15 N/cm with a torque gauge and ultimate tensile strength values determined. The procedure was duplicated using 15 Nobelpharma gold screws from another lot tightened to 0, 10, and 20 N/cm. Within each of the test groups, there was no significant difference in the ultimate tensile strength among the three preload torques. However, a paired t test (P = 0.005) determined that there was a significant difference between the two lots with respect to the ultimate tensile strength of the screws preloaded to 10 N/cm. Altering the preload torque applied to Nobelpharma gold-retaining screws does not affect their ultimate tensile strength. The ultimate tensile strength of the screws from the two lots differed, suggesting an unannounced change in component specifications.