Distinct interactions of αA-crystallin with homologous substrate proteins, δ-crystallin and argininosuccinate lyase, under thermal stress

δ-Crystallin is a taxon-specific eye lens protein that was recruited from argininosuccinate lyase (ASL) through gene sharing. ASL is a metabolic enzyme that catalyzes the reversible conversion of argininosuccinate into arginine and fumarate and shares about 70% sequence identity and similar overall topology with δ-crystallin. ASL has a lower thermal stability than δ-crystallin. In this study, we show that the small heat shock protein, αA-crystallin, functions as a molecular chaperone, and enhanced thermal stability of both δ-crystallin and ASL. The stoichiometry for efficient protection of the two substrate proteins by αA-crystallin was determined by slowly increasing the temperature. N- or C-terminal truncated mutants of δ-crystallin co-incubated with αA-crystallin showed higher thermal stability than wild-type enzyme, and the stoichiometry for efficient protection was the same. Thermal unfolding of δ-crystallin or ASL in the presence of αA-crystallin followed a similar three-state model, as determined by circular dichroism analyses. A stable intermediate which retained about 30% α-helical structure was observed. Protection from thermal denaturation by αA-crystallin was by interaction with partly unfolded ASL or δ-crystallin to form high molecular weight heteroligomers, as judged by size-exclusive chromatography and SDS-PAGE analyses. Aggregate formation of ASL was significantly reduced in the presence of αA-crystallin. The extent of protection of ASL and δ-crystallin at different ratios of αA-crystallin were described by hyperbolic and sigmoidal curves, respectively. These results suggest the preferential recognition of partly unfolded ASL by αA-crystallin. In contrast, unstable δ-crystallin might trigger a cooperative interaction by higher stoichiometries of αA-crystallin leading to fuller protection. The different interactions of αA-crystallin with the two homologous but functionally different substrate proteins show its behavior as a chaperone is variable.